claim_id,study,year,journal,doi,organism_group,organism,kind_of_learning,measure,role,tests_claim,independent_of_original,outcome_of_test,n,n_what,what_the_authors_report,verdict_code,verdict,independent_repeats,other_species_tests,same_lab_followups,comments_or_letters,dispute,openalex_citations_2026_11_10,paper_licence,text_read,note gagliano2014,Gagliano 2014,2014,Oecologia,https://doi.org/10.1007/s00442-013-2873-7,Plants,Mimosa pudica,habituation,behaviour,original,,,,,,"Leaf-folding in response to repeated drops habituates, more strongly and for longer in costly environments, and the plants still showed the learned response after a month undisturbed.",D,Contested,,,,biegler2018 gagliano2018r,a published comment disputes it (biegler2018),352,Publisher copyright,abstract,Full text behind a paywall: n not read. gagliano2016,Gagliano 2016,2016,Scientific reports,https://doi.org/10.1038/srep38427,Plants,Pisum sativum (garden pea),associative,behaviour,original,,,,83,seedlings in Experiment 2 (Y-maze),"Pea seedlings trained in a Y-maze with a fan (neutral cue) before light grew toward the fan alone, which the authors call associative learning.",B,Repeated: effect not found,markel2020,,,,the original authors dispute the repeat's design (gagliano2020c); the replicator replied (markel2020r),246,CC BY,full text, markel2020,Markel 2020,2020,eLife,https://doi.org/10.7554/elife.57614,Plants,Pisum sativum (garden pea),associative,behaviour,repeat,gagliano2016,yes,not found,121,plants in the largest comparison (61 + 60),A replication with a larger sample and blinded scoring found no significant difference between trained and control plants.,,,,,,,,51,CC BY,full text,The original authors answered in print (Gagliano et al. 2020) that the protocol was unsuitable; the replicator replied. ponkshe2024,Ponkshe 2024,2024,Quarterly journal of experimental psychology (2006),https://doi.org/10.1177/17470218231203078,Plants,Pisum sativum (garden pea),associative,behaviour,repeat,gagliano2016,yes,not stated,,,Reports 11 practical issues met while trying to replicate the pea experiment; the abstract gives no effect result.,,,,,,,,14,Publisher copyright,abstract, dener2016,Dener 2016,2016,Current biology : CB,https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2016.05.008,Plants,Pisum sativum (garden pea),decision,behaviour,original,,,,,,"Split-root pea plants put more root growth on the variable side when mean nutrients were low and on the constant side when high, as risk-sensitivity theory predicts; the authors note non-adaptive mechanisms may explain part.",F,No repeat found,,,,,,104,Publisher copyright,abstract, bohm2016,Böhm 2016,2016,Current biology : CB,https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2015.11.057,Plants,Dionaea muscipula (Venus flytrap),memory,molecular,original,,,,,,"The trap counts touch-induced action potentials: the jasmonate pathway switches on after the second stimulus and digestive genes after more than three; a single touch is ""memorized"" as a subthreshold signal.",E,Same laboratory only,,,iosip2023,,,181,CC BY-NC-ND,full text, iosip2023,Iosip 2023,2023,Current biology : CB,https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2022.12.058,Plants,Dionaea muscipula (Venus flytrap),memory,molecular,followup,bohm2016,no,found,,,A Venus flytrap mutant still fires touch action potentials but cannot count them and does not enter the hunting cycle; the authors describe a calcium clock for memory and decision.,,,,,,,,13,Publisher copyright,abstract, volkov2008,Volkov 2008,2008,Plant signaling & behavior,https://doi.org/10.4161/psb.3.7.5684,Plants,Dionaea muscipula (Venus flytrap),memory,molecular,original,,,,,,"The trap sums small electrical charges that alone do not close it and shuts when a threshold is reached, which the authors call short-term electrical memory.",E,Same laboratory only,,,volkov2009,,,56,Publisher copyright,abstract, volkov2009,Volkov 2009,2009,"Bioelectrochemistry (Amsterdam, Netherlands)",https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bioelechem.2009.03.005,Plants,Dionaea muscipula (Venus flytrap),memory,molecular,followup,volkov2008,no,found,,,"Measured the charge that closes the trap: 8 microcoulombs (small trap), 9 (large trap), 4.1 at 28-36 degrees C; the cumulative effect points to short-term electrical memory.",,,,,,,,76,Publisher copyright,abstract, bhandawat2020,Bhandawat 2020,2020,Communicative & integrative biology,https://doi.org/10.1080/19420889.2020.1713426,Plants,Arabidopsis thaliana,associative,molecular,original,,,,,,"Seedlings conditioned with music and heat switched on heat-response genes more strongly than with music alone; the authors call this associative learning (gene expression, not movement).",F,No repeat found,,,,,,27,CC BY,full text, farkas2025,Farkas 2025,2025,Plant signaling & behavior,https://doi.org/10.1080/15592324.2025.2556982,Plants,Solanum lycopersicum (tomato),associative,molecular,original,,,,168,plants in the experiments,"Tomato plants conditioned with ultrasound and drought used one stimulus as a predictor of the other in 3 of 4 target genes; transcript levels also showed habituation or sustained induction (gene expression, not movement).",F,No repeat found,,,,,,6,CC BY,full text, salvalaio2024,Salvalaio 2024,2024,Plant physiology,https://doi.org/10.1093/plphys/kiad686,Plants,Arabidopsis thaliana (roots),habituation,behaviour,original,,,,71,roots in the largest group (1.5 V/cm),"Roots exposed for hours to a weak electric field overshoot and then habituate in their bending, and past exposures change the later response (hysteresis).",F,No repeat found,,,,,,5,CC BY,full text, mittelbach2019,Mittelbach 2019,2019,Plant signaling & behavior,https://doi.org/10.1080/15592324.2019.1595320,Plants,Nasa poissoniana (Loasaceae),memory,behaviour,original,,,,,,Stamens presented pollen earlier after flowers had been touched at fixed intervals; the authors report first evidence of pre-emptive stamen presentation based on remembered visit intervals.,F,No repeat found,,,,,,16,Publisher copyright,abstract, vishton2025,Vishton 2025,2025,Cognitive science,https://doi.org/10.1111/cogs.70161,Plants,Mimosa pudica,memory,behaviour,original,,,,,,"Over 15 days of two lit days then one dark day, leaf movements shifted to follow the pattern; the authors say movement tracks the number of illumination events.",F,No repeat found,,,,,,1,CC BY,abstract, nakagaki2000,Nakagaki 2000,2000,Nature,https://doi.org/10.1038/35035159,Slime moulds,Physarum polycephalum,decision,behaviour,original,,,,,,The plasmodium finds the shortest path through a maze between two food sources.,F,No repeat found,,,,,,1032,CC BY-NC-ND,the author's own 2001 summary (no abstract in PubMed),Nature article behind a paywall with no abstract in PubMed; the claim is in the title and in the same author's 2001 summary (PMID 11763236). saigusa2008,Saigusa 2008,2008,Physical review letters,https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.100.018101,Slime moulds,Physarum polycephalum,memory,behaviour,original,,,,,,"After three unfavourable pulses at fixed intervals the plasmodia slowed again at the time the next pulse would have come, which the authors read as anticipation.",C,Tested in another species,,mueller2026,,,,413,Publisher copyright,abstract, mueller2026,Mueller 2026,2026,Scientific reports,https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-026-37298-0,Amoebae,Amoeba proteus,memory,behaviour,other_species,saigusa2008,yes,found,21,cells tested,"After four periodic blue-light pulses the amoebae slowed at the time the next pulse would have come, as in the slime mould study.",,,,,,,,1,CC BY,full text, latty2011a,Latty 2011,2011,Proceedings. Biological sciences,https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2010.1045,Slime moulds,Physarum polycephalum,decision,behaviour,original,,,,,,"Preferences were transitive, but adding a third, inferior food option raised the preference for the focal one, which breaks the independence-of-irrelevant-alternatives rule.",C,Tested in another species,,yin2025,,,,160,Publisher copyright,abstract, yin2025,Yin 2025,2025,Journal of basic microbiology,https://doi.org/10.1002/jobm.70023,Slime moulds,Physarella oblonga,decision,behaviour,other_species,latty2011a,yes,found,,,"Added a third yeast species as a decoy and the slime mould shifted its preference between two others (a decoy effect), in a different species of slime mould.",,,,,,,,2,Publisher copyright,abstract, latty2011b,Latty 2011,2011,Proceedings. Biological sciences,https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2010.1624,Slime moulds,Physarum polycephalum,decision,behaviour,original,,,,,,"Individuals that chose fast made more costly errors (picked the worst of three foods), a speed-accuracy trade-off that light and hunger changed.",F,No repeat found,,,,,,83,Publisher copyright,abstract, latty2015,Latty 2015,2015,The Journal of experimental biology,https://doi.org/10.1242/jeb.116533,Slime moulds,Physarum polycephalum,decision,behaviour,original,,,,,,"Time spent in a food patch rose after the plasmodium engulfed a high-quality food item, so patch leaving followed a rule based on experience inside the patch (a second slime mould, Didymium bahiense, was tested too).",F,No repeat found,,,,,,33,Publisher copyright,abstract, dussutour2019,Dussutour 2019,2019,Proceedings. Biological sciences,https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2018.2825,Slime moulds,Physarum polycephalum,decision,behaviour,original,,,,,,"Slow explorers made more accurate choices than fast explorers, and longer sampling raised accuracy: a speed-accuracy link tied to individual differences between cells.",F,No repeat found,,,,,,28,Publisher copyright,abstract, reid2012,Reid 2012,2012,Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1215037109,Slime moulds,Physarum polycephalum,memory,behaviour,original,,,,,,"The plasmodium avoids areas it has already explored, and so escapes a U-shaped trap on its way to food; the authors call this an externalized spatial memory.",F,No repeat found,,,,,,294,Publisher copyright,abstract, reid2016,Reid 2016,2016,"Journal of the Royal Society, Interface",https://doi.org/10.1098/rsif.2016.0030,Slime moulds,Physarum polycephalum,decision,behaviour,original,,,,,,"In a two-armed bandit task the cell compared options, integrated repeated samples and combined reward frequency with magnitude, which the authors model as an exploit-in-proportion algorithm.",F,No repeat found,,,,,,105,CC BY,abstract, boisseau2016,Boisseau 2016,2016,Proceedings. Biological sciences,https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2016.0446,Slime moulds,Physarum polycephalum,habituation,behaviour,original,,,,,,"Plasmodia learnt to cross bridges with quinine or caffeine when the stimulus was repeated, responded again after a pause, and the effect was specific to the stimulus.",A,Repeated: effect found,yoneoka2023,,vogel2016 boussard2019,,,259,Publisher copyright,abstract, yoneoka2023,Yoneoka 2023,2023,Frontiers in cell and developmental biology,https://doi.org/10.3389/fcell.2023.1249165,Slime moulds,Physarum polycephalum,habituation,behaviour,repeat,boisseau2016,yes,found,,,"Ran the quinine-bridge habituation experiment ""in the same manner"" as the original and observed habituation; the transport network changed from tree to mesh while the cell habituated.",,,,,,,,3,CC BY,full text, vogel2016,Vogel 2016,2016,Proceedings. Biological sciences,https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2016.2382,Slime moulds,Physarum polycephalum,habituation,behaviour,followup,boisseau2016,no,found,,,"A slime mould habituated to a repellent passed the response on to naive ones by cell fusion, which had to last a certain time.",,,,,,,,92,Publisher copyright,abstract, boussard2019,Boussard 2019,2019,"Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences",https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2018.0368,Slime moulds,Physarum polycephalum,memory,behaviour,followup,boisseau2016,no,found,,,"Habituation to sodium survived a dormant stage of one month; the slime mould absorbed and kept the repellent, which the authors call a circulating memory.",,,,,,,,71,Publisher copyright,abstract, kramar2021,Kramar 2021,2021,Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2007815118,Slime moulds,Physarum polycephalum,memory,behaviour,original,,,,,,"Tubes of the plasmodium grow or shrink around a food source, so the food location is stored in the tube-diameter pattern and shapes later migration.",D,Contested,,,,reiber2021,a published letter disputes it (reiber2021),104,Publisher copyright,abstract, kippenberger2023,Kippenberger 2023,2023,International journal of molecular sciences,https://doi.org/10.3390/ijms24076287,Slime moulds,Physarum polycephalum,memory,behaviour,original,,,,,,In a maze of Y-branches the cell was a quick learner at the first bifurcations of finding the rewarded branch; food soaked with propofol was chosen less.,F,No repeat found,,,,,,9,CC BY,abstract, kuttner2026,Kuttner 2026,2026,Protist,https://doi.org/10.1016/j.protis.2026.126156,Slime moulds,Physarum polycephalum,memory,behaviour,original,,,,1274,plasmodia,Spontaneous alternation in T-mazes appeared only at the shortest distance (3 mm); the authors say it may reveal spatial memory but cannot rule out the maze shape.,F,No repeat found,,,,,,0,CC BY,abstract, skoge2014,Skoge 2014,2014,Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1412197111,Amoebae,Dictyostelium discoideum,memory,behaviour,original,,,,,,"Cells kept moving toward the source of chemical waves in the back of the wave for a natural 6-minute period and increasingly reversed for longer periods, which the authors call cellular memory.",E,Same laboratory only,,,karmakar2021,,,133,Publisher copyright,abstract, karmakar2021,Karmakar 2021,2021,Physical review. E,https://doi.org/10.1103/physreve.103.012402,Amoebae,Dictyostelium discoideum,memory,behaviour,followup,skoge2014,no,found,,,The memory depends on the background level of the chemical: chemotaxis was best at intermediate levels and fell to almost zero at high ones.,,,,,,,,25,Publisher copyright,abstract, vanhaastert2021,van 2021,2021,PloS one,https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0246345,Amoebae,Dictyostelium discoideum,memory,behaviour,original,,,,,,"Two memories steer movement: about 20 seconds of the last pseudopod position, and about 2 minutes of the activity of the last ten pseudopods.",F,No repeat found,,,,,,19,CC BY,abstract, delafuente2019,De 2019,2019,Nature communications,https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-019-11677-w,Amoebae,Amoeba proteus,associative,behaviour,original,,,,160,amoebae in the conditioned-behaviour test,Amoebae that moved toward an electrode while a chemical peptide was present kept moving that way for 44 minutes on average after the peptide was removed.,E,Same laboratory only,,,carrasco2021,,,62,CC BY,full text, carrasco2021,Carrasco-Pujante 2021,2021,Frontiers in microbiology,https://doi.org/10.3389/fmicb.2021.707086,Amoebae,"Amoeba proteus, Metamoeba leningradensis, Amoeba borokensis",associative,behaviour,followup,delafuente2019,no,found,2000,"cells (more than 2,000)","Tracked more than 2,000 cells of three amoeba species and again found the conditioned migration pattern.",,,,,,,,34,CC BY,abstract, jennings1906,Jennings 1906,1906,Behavior of the Lower Organisms (book),,Ciliates,Stentor roeseli,habituation,behaviour,original,,,,,,"Jennings described a hierarchy of responses to repeated stimulation in the sessile ciliate Stentor roeseli, among the most complex behaviours reported for a single cell.",A,Repeated: effect found,dexter2019,,,,,,"Public domain (1906 book, not read as text)",abstract of a later paper (Dexter et al. 2019); the 1906 book is not online as text,Reported non-reproducible in 1967 with another species (S. coeruleus). dexter2019,Dexter 2019,2019,Current biology : CB,https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2019.10.059,Ciliates,Stentor roeseli,habituation,behaviour,repeat,jennings1906,yes,found,,,"Using the correct species, the authors confirmed Jennings' observations: S. roeseli shows a hierarchy of avoidance behaviours, with large differences between cells.",,,,,,,,121,Publisher copyright,abstract, wood1988a,Wood 1988,1988,The Journal of neuroscience : the official journal of the Society for Neuroscience,https://doi.org/10.1523/jneurosci.08-07-02248.1988,Ciliates,Stentor coeruleus,habituation,behaviour,original,,,,,,Stentor habituates to repeated mechanical taps; the drop in response tracks a smaller receptor potential and depends mainly on action potentials.,A,Repeated: effect found,rajan2023,stipatus2026,wood1988b,,,38,CC BY-NC-SA,abstract, wood1988b,Wood 1988,1988,The Journal of neuroscience : the official journal of the Society for Neuroscience,https://doi.org/10.1523/jneurosci.08-07-02254.1988,Ciliates,Stentor coeruleus,habituation,behaviour,followup,wood1988a,no,found,,,"Habituation comes from a change in the mechanoreceptor channels (the voltage-dependent part of the current became steeper), not from fewer channels.",,,,,,,,55,CC BY-NC-SA,abstract, rajan2023,Rajan 2023,2023,Current biology : CB,https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2022.11.010,Ciliates,Stentor coeruleus,habituation,behaviour,repeat,wood1988a,yes,found,22,cells in the first single-cell analysis,"Habituation to repeated taps was seen in single cells, but as one step-like switch per cell, not the graded decline earlier studies reported.",,,,,,,,69,CC BY,full text,"Confirms the effect; disagrees on its shape (step, not graded)." rajan2026,Rajan 2026,2026,Current biology : CB,https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2026.03.080,Ciliates,Stentor coeruleus,habituation,behaviour,extension,wood1988a,yes,found,,,Blocking protein synthesis sped up habituation and lengthened memory; calcium signalling and protein phosphorylation were implicated.,,,,,,,,6,CC BY,abstract, stipatus2026,Rajan 2026,2026,Scientific reports,https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-026-40277-0,Ciliates,Stentor stipatus,habituation,behaviour,other_species,wood1988a,yes,found,,,A newly described Stentor species also habituates to repeated taps (title and behavioural characterisation).,,,,,,,,2,CC BY-NC-ND,abstract, armus2006,Armus 2006,2006,Psychological reports,https://doi.org/10.2466/pr0.98.3.705-711,Ciliates,Paramecium caudatum,associative,behaviour,original,,,,,,Paramecia trained with electric shock on a brightness discrimination task: the authors write that learning may have occurred.,A,Repeated: effect found,alipour2022,,mingee2009,,,46,Publisher copyright,abstract, mingee2009,Mingee 2009,2009,Psychological reports,https://doi.org/10.2466/pr0.105.2.533-538,Ciliates,Paramecium caudatum,associative,behaviour,followup,armus2006,no,not found,40,paramecia,Same laboratory: paramecia did not learn a discrete action with shock as reinforcer (sample of 40).,,,,,,,,4,Publisher copyright,abstract, alipour2022,Alipour 2022,2022,Basic and clinical neuroscience,https://doi.org/10.32598/bcn.2021.2462.1,Ciliates,Paramecium caudatum,associative,behaviour,repeat,armus2006,yes,found,105,paramecia in four groups (30 + 23 + 26 + 26),"Used the Armus brightness-and-shock task: trained paramecia differed from controls; midazolam disrupted the learning, a microtubule drug did not.",,,,,,,,0,CC BY-NC,full text, csaba1982,Csaba 1982,1982,Experimental cell biology,https://doi.org/10.1159/000163158,Ciliates,Tetrahymena pyriformis,memory,molecular,original,,,,,,"A single dose of a hormone-like molecule raised cell division for as many as 500 generations and re-exposure enhanced it again, which the authors call receptor ""memory"".",E,Same laboratory only,,,csaba1984,,,28,Publisher copyright,abstract,Hormonal imprinting; one laboratory published a long series (1977-1994 in our search). csaba1984,Csaba 1984,1984,Experimental cell biology,,Ciliates,Tetrahymena pyriformis,memory,molecular,followup,csaba1982,no,found,,,Spaced exposures induced the memory better than one long exposure and a foreign hormone could extinguish it (retroactive interference).,,,,,,,,,Publisher copyright,abstract, fukasawa2020,Fukasawa 2020,2020,The ISME journal,https://doi.org/10.1038/s41396-019-0536-3,Fungi,Phanerochaete velutina,memory,behaviour,original,,,,180,inocula (sample size for the regrowth test),Mycelium regrew from 67% of inocula moved to fresh soil; a bait-size threshold cued the move; the authors tested the mycelium's memory of growth direction.,C,Tested in another species,,parise2025,,,,74,CC BY,abstract, parise2025,Parise 2025,2025,Communicative & integrative biology,https://doi.org/10.1080/19420889.2025.2580130,Fungi,Laccaria bicolor,memory,behaviour,other_species,fukasawa2020,yes,not found,,,A similar test of memory of the food direction in an ectomycorrhizal fungus found no evidence of memory.,,,,,,,,0,CC BY,abstract,